For EU, Effort to End Overfishing Is Coming Down to the Wire

At its most critical meeting this year, Fisheries Council must follow science

For EU, Effort to End Overfishing Is Coming Down to the Wire
The Pew Charitable Trusts

European fisheries ministers will meet in Brussels 17-18 December to set fishing limits for over 100 fish stocks; the meeting will be the Agriculture and Fisheries Council’s third—and final—of this autumn and, if past sessions are any indication, could go into the early morning hours of the 19th.

The gathering follows months of preparation that kicked off in earnest in June when the International Council for Exploration of the Sea (ICES) released scientific advice covering dozens of stocks, and the European Commission issued a Communication on progress toward meeting the goals laid out in the Common Fisheries Policy (CFP).

As part of that lead-up, The Pew Charitable Trusts hosted the Countdown to 2020 conference—a reference to the CFP deadline for ending overfishing in European Union (EU) waters—where European Commissioner for Environment, Maritime Affairs and Fisheries Karmenu Vella emphasized the urgent need to meet that target. That statement is critical right now: Member-state ministers often use the December Council meeting to push for deadline extensions and inflate catches rather than respect the limit advised by scientists. Commissioner Vella and the Council of the European Union Presidency, currently held by Austria (@EU2018AT), need public support to hold ministers to their commitments, especially with the 2020 deadline approaching so quickly.

Marine life
Marine life
Fact Sheet

10 Reasons to End Overfishing in Europe

Quick View
Fact Sheet

Management of fisheries in the European Union has improved over the past 15 years, but the fishing limits set by EU fisheries ministers too often exceed the levels advised by scientists. That prevents Europeans from realising many of the benefits of sustainable, productive fish stocks and fisheries.

Intense lobbying typically surrounds the Council meeting, with delegations shuttling between the Council building and nearby hotels to relay and reconsider national priorities with industry representatives; last year, the Council did not adjourn until around 6.30 a.m. on day three.

Ultimately ministers are responsible for fishing limits under the CFP, and for explaining any limits they set that exceed the level advised by scientists. The data are as clear as the 2020 deadline: to end overfishing, ministers must set limits based on science.

The outcome of this December meeting is a test of the EU’s policies, not just domestically but on the world stage—the United Nations’ Sustainable Development Goals and other international commitments also carry a 2020 deadline for ending overfishing. World leaders are increasingly turning their attention to addressing the risks our oceans face. Commissioner Vella, for example, hosted a panel on Global Ocean Leadership at the Our Ocean conference in October in Bali, Indonesia, where he called for more to be done to protect the seas and the species that live in them.

Overfishing in the EU
Overfishing in the EU
Video

How to End Overfishing in the EU

Quick View
Video

EU fisheries are in trouble. Currently, nearly 50 per cent of fish stocks are overfished in the North Sea and Northeast Atlantic—and more than 90 per cent in the Mediterranean Sea. We explain the dire consequences for both the European Union economy and marine environment if overfishing continues and lay out a plan of action for how fisheries ministers can end overfishing—and how you can help. Learn more at https://pewtrusts.org/endeuoverfishing.

So, when they meet in Brussels later this month, ministers need to stop delaying and secure sustainable EU fisheries. We are urging ministers to #RespectTheLimit.

For more on this meeting we’ve summarized how the decisions are made and how ministers have done in recent years in prior analysis pieces, an animation, an issue brief, and a summary of a conference Pew hosted in February.

Andrew Clayton directs The Pew Charitable Trusts’ efforts to end overfishing in Northwestern Europe.

Quiz

Do You Know What's Really Going On in EU Fisheries?

Quick View
Quiz

Do You Know What's Really Going On in EU Fisheries?

From the North, Celtic and Irish seas to the Atlantic Ocean, Europe’s north-western waters harbour a rich array of life. Can you tell a hake from a herring, a sardine from a sole, or a cod from a Common Fisheries Policy? Test your fish knowledge with our quiz.

Podcast

The Future of Fish and Chips

Quick View
Podcast

Overfishing has strained most global fish stocks. But the European Union has made progress bringing back one popular species: North Atlantic cod. The flaky white fish—a British staple when battered and served with chips—has rebounded after plummeting to critically low levels in the late 2000s. In this episode, we go to one of London’s oldest fish and chips restaurants and learn how quotas can be used to help other stocks recover.