Official report confirms massive misuse of EU fisheries funds

Billions of euros to promote sustainable fishing are doing the reverse

Press Releases and Statements December 12, 2011 Read time:

Projects: OCEAN2012

OCEAN2012 and Corey Arnold

Brussels - The EU Court of Auditors today published a report (PDF) damning costly failures to eliminate overfishing in Europe.

The report found that the multi-billion euro European Fisheries Fund designed to balance fishing activities at sustainable levels is actually doing the reverse. Loopholes mean that fleet owners are receiving subsidies to increase the capacity and fishing power of their vessels, adding to fleet overcapacity. A small fraction of the money available for scrapping is being used as intended, with most being spent on vessels that are old or no longer active.

The court did not stop at criticising the misspending of taxpayers’ money, but highlighted fundamental flaws in the existing fleet adjustment rules.

The report warns that fleet overcapacity is driving the depletion of fish stocks, threatening marine life and the viability of fishing sector and coastal communities. The result is that three out of four European fish stocks are overfished.

Birdlife Europe, Greenpeace, OCEAN2012, Seas At Risk and WWF are urging the European Parliament and Council of Ministers to follow the court’s recommendations. The report shows that the Common Fisheries Policy (CFP) reform will be meaningless unless measures are based on a full assessment of the fishing capacity coupled with deadlines for fleet reductions, the groups argue.

The European Commission’s reform proposals are not up to the task:

European Maritime & Fisheries Fund (replacing the European Fisheries Fund) - Unless safeguards are put in place, there is little evidence that subsidies will stop fuelling overcapacity let alone reverse it. For instance, the recent Commission proposal does not require member states to assess the balance between fishing capacity and stocks before receiving modernisation funds.

CFP reform – Clear timelines and targets for fleet reductions should be introduced in the revised proposals. Moreover, the text should be amended to create a wider range of options for allocating fishing rights, introducing preferential access for those that fish in the most sustainable and responsible way.

Fisheries ministers will meet on 16 December to set fishing quotas for 2012. These should be set in line with the scientific advice, and consistent with the goal to recover fish stocks to above levels that can produce maximum sustainable yields by 2015, the groups say.

Notes to the editor:

Press release also available in Español (PDF)
The court investigated spending in the field of fisheries in seven member states (Denmark, France, Italy, Poland, Portugal, Spain and the UK) and found that member states have not fulfilled their obligation under the CFP of putting in place effective measures to match fishing capacity to fishing opportunities. Four of the seven member states examined in the audit had set inadequate targets for reducing capacity.
A similar report, recently published by the EU Commission, identifies Spain, France, Ireland, Cyprus, Poland, and Portugal as not providing an assessment of fleet capacity in relation to fishing opportunities and Sweden, Spain and the United Kingdom as not describing their fleets in relation to fisheries. (COM(2011) 354 final.) Reforming EU Fisheries Subsidies. A joint NGO discussion paper & technical resource October 2011
“Fleet overcapacity is driving overfishing”, Joint NGO Position Paper (PDF), November 2011