France’s New Marine Protection Strategy Should Include Stronger Safeguards, Experts Say

Science shows that greatly limiting extractive activities yields the most benefits to ocean and people

France’s New Marine Protection Strategy Should Include Stronger Safeguards, Experts Say
Blue striped tamarin wrasse
Blue striped tamarin wrasse swim in French Polynesian waters around the Austral Islands, an area rich in marine biodiversity that would benefit from high protections.
Ian Skipworth

In January, France unveiled its new global marine conservation strategy with a goal of protecting 30% of its waters by 2022; a third of that would be shielded by “high protections” under the plan, meaning that extractive activities would not be allowed in the areas. Achieving these goals would be a major step forward for global ocean health because France has the world’s second-largest exclusive economic zone (EEZ)—covering 11,691,000 square kilometers (4,514,000 square miles)—largely because of its numerous overseas territories, including French Polynesia, New Caledonia, and the French Southern and Antarctic Lands (TAAF)

Leading up to France’s announcement, the Pew Bertarelli Ocean Legacy Project partnered with the International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN) French Committee to bring experts and stakeholders together in a series of online conferences exploring the need for, and benefits and importance of, high marine protection—which should be the government’s focus now, given that it has almost achieved the 30% goal.

Marine protected areas benefit ocean health and coastal communities

The first conference of this series, held in September 2020, featured 12 French experts focused on ocean health and effective approaches to conserving biodiversity, including establishing fully safeguarded, well-managed marine protected areas (MPAs).

The experts explained that MPAs, specifically those with a high level of protection, provide measurable benefits to marine ecosystems and surrounding communities. Such MPAs can protect seagrasses and reefs, which buffer coastal communities from the full impact of waves and safeguard coastlines from erosion. They also can promote carbon sequestration by preserving mangrove forests, which can absorb at least three times as much carbon as terrestrial tropical forests.  

In addition, conference participants highlighted how MPAs can benefit local economies. Research proves that fish are larger and more numerous inside an MPA than outside. As fish populations mature and grow, they spill over into fishing grounds, generating greater catch and income for fisherman. MPAs can also help generate significant revenue related to tourism.  

The importance of high protection

The potential benefits of MPAs can be fully realized only if those areas are large and highly protected, according to experts. Although 23.5% of French maritime waters are designated as MPAs, some still permit activities such as industrial fishing that undermine the intended conservation benefits of the protections. According to a recent paper published in the journal Marine Policy, less than 2% of French waters are fully or highly protected, and 80% of that total is concentrated in a single overseas territory: TAAF.

Panelists at another conference, held online in November 2020, noted that these highly protected waters are predominantly located in overseas territories with little traffic and less exposure to human pressures and therefore indicate a “lack of representativeness” of France’s marine habitats worldwide. During the conference, experts recommended that France establish more highly protected MPAs—that better represent key habitats—across its territorial waters.

As part of its strategy announcement, France pledged to develop three three-year action plans with input from its overseas territories. The first of these plans was released in January, and the implementation of this plan provides France with an opportunity to enhance its marine protection in order to deliver significant ecological benefits. This would require it to create highly protected MPAs that restrict all extractive and damaging activities, such as industrial fishing.

A global call for action

The best available science tells us that we need to protect at least 30% of the ocean to conserve biodiversity and ecosystems, improve long-term food security, and protect ocean-based livelihoods. Today, more than 70 countries, including France, have publicly committed to achieve this goal by 2030, and more than 100 countries are united in their support for a global biodiversity target to significantly increase the protection and conservation of the planet’s ocean over the next decade. France plays a leading role in promoting the 30% global target through the High Ambition Coalition. With this global momentum, countries can deliver a post-2020 framework at the 15th Conference of the Parties to the Convention on Biological Diversity later this year; that framework should include a robust ocean target that calls for effective marine protections, with the focus on areas important for biodiversity and ecosystem services.

Jérôme Petit is a senior manager with the Pew Bertarelli Ocean Legacy Project in French Polynesia.

Limpets
Limpets
Fact Sheet

A Way to Safeguard Biodiversity and Protect Ocean Habitat

Quick View
Fact Sheet

Ocean health is critical to all life on this planet. Phytoplankton, the microscopic plants found in the sunlit area of almost all oceans, generate about half of the Earth’s oxygen, and the complex interaction between the ocean and the atmosphere sustains our climate.

Wave crashing
Wave crashing

The Drive to Protect 30% of the Ocean by 2030

Quick View

Effective marine conservation can help people and nature, conserving critical marine habitat where species may thrive, and significantly boost the global economy, for example by fostering healthy and sustainable fisheries. Pew is working with partners to ensure that the international community builds on this momentum and support to establish and sustain protections to conserve biodiversity in the most important ocean environments.

Large group of Yellowfin tuna
Large group of Yellowfin tuna
Article

French Polynesia's Best Path Is Robust Protections

Quick View
Article

French Polynesia’s diverse marine ecosystem harbors more than 20 species of sharks and an exceptionally healthy coral reef system that supports 176 coral and 1,024 fish species—including some found nowhere else.