Zoning and Student Housing in La Plaza Vieja

Location Flagstaff Arizona
Organization La Plaza Vieja Neighborhood Association, residents of Arrowhead Village, Hermosa Vida community organizers, Department of Anthropology at Northern Arizona University

The La Plaza Vieja Neighborhood Association, residents of Arrowhead Village, Hermosa Vida community organizers, the Department of Anthropology at Northern Arizona University, and an independent HIA consultant conducted a rapid HIA to examine the potential health effects a local rezoning proposal intended to accommodate new student housing in Flagstaff, Arizona.

The HIA found that the zoning code change and subsequent housing development would displace approximately 170 people living in 56 mobile homes in Arrowhead Village, which could result in increased housing costs—and could in turn present a range of physical and mental health risks—for residents and could affect the health of other area residents through changes in traffic safety and crime. The HIA made several recommendations to mitigate potential effects, including providing legally binding relocation packages for displaced residents before they must vacate and requiring the developer to purchase and develop land for mobile homes that is close to schools, employment, and affordable grocery stores and to allow flexibility in resident move-out dates to prevent cost burden on displaced residents. The HIA also offered recommendations to alleviate potential neighborhood preservation effects, including traffic calming strategies, additional security measures such as 24-hour on-site staff, and changes to the building’s specifications such as reducing the total number of students it will house and shortening it to match the tallest existing building in the neighborhood. 

Members of the HIA team and several community partners cited the findings and recommendations in written and oral testimony to the local planning and zoning commission, which recommended denial of the proposed development. The developer ultimately withdrew the application.

HIAs and Other Resources
Data Visualization

Search Our Toolkit

View the toolkit
Quick View
Data Visualization

Search Our Toolkit

The Health Impact Project’s toolkit contains resources that help communities, agencies, and other organizations take action to improve public health. The toolkit offers a collection of health impact assessments, guides, and other research to support policymakers’ efforts to consider health when making decisions across sectors, such as housing, planning, and education.

View the toolkit
At A Glance
  • Status:
  • Publication date:
    2014, June
  • Decision-making levels:
  • Sectors:
    Planning and zoning, Housing
  • Additional topic areas:
    Siting, Mental/behavioral health
  • Drivers of health:
    Safe, affordable, and healthy housing, Employment, Family and social support, Access to services/medical care, Safe street infrastructure, Cultural well-being, Community safety
  • Affected populations:
  • Community types:
  • Research methods:
    Literature review, Qualitative research, Stakeholder interviews
  • Funding source:
    Other funding