Let’s Start a Conversation About Debt and Race in Philadelphia

A Conversation About Debt and Race in Philadelphia
Capitolo playground
Lexey Swall GRAIN for The Pew Charitable Trusts

Debt is an issue for many Philadelphians, and it’s time to talk about it.

Large amounts of debt can lead to financial crisis, housing instability, and intergenerational financial vulnerability. In Philadelphia, people are burdened by credit card debt, high-cost loans, utility bills, and rental housing costs; many are caught in the debt trap, a cycle of re-borrowing to keep up with what, for them, are unaffordable payments. And for residents caught in this cycle, it can feel like there is no escape.

Although many Philadelphians are in debt—often because they must borrow to pay for basic necessities—there hasn’t been a larger conversation about who is most affected and the impact debt has had on their lives. It’s time to start that dialogue.

Research conducted independently by Community Legal Services of Philadelphia (CLS) and by The Pew Charitable Trusts shows that low- and middle-income Black and Hispanic households are often hardest hit by debt. In Municipal Court, where companies that buy consumer debt and try to collect on it for a profit file the majority of small claims cases, Black Philadelphians are overrepresented as defendants compared with their share of households in the city. Pew data shows that although 91% of plaintiffs were represented by lawyers in Philadelphia small claims cases filed from 2013 to 2018, only 12% of defendants had an attorney—and that defendants have better outcomes with a lawyer.

Pew’s research highlighted that a third of small claims cases were dismissed without service—meaning the defendant was never notified of the case—and that nearly 50% of cases among defendants without an attorney ended in default judgments. Conversely, only 17% of cases involving defendants who had counsel resulted in default judgments against the defendants. Judgments in small claims cases follow people for decades, freezing their bank accounts and forcing them to avoid opening new ones; draining their home equity; and sometimes blocking the loan modifications they need to prevent foreclosure. Defendants also report falling behind on utility payments and other bills, as well as going without food, transportation, or other basic needs in order to pay the judgments against them.

Eviction court cases can also create debt for families, negatively affect credit scores, and lead to homelessness. CLS found that from March to December 2020, landlords filed court actions to evict nearly 3,000 Philadelphia families, primarily in Black and Hispanic communities, even though some eviction actions were stayed because of COVID-19 moratoriums; these numbers are likely to increase when the moratoriums are lifted. And because there is currently no process to remove an eviction from a tenant’s record, these judgements often limit tenants’ future rental options, locking them out from safe, quality housing for years to come.

Many Philadelphians are struggling to pay other housing related costs such as utilities; when those bills go unpaid, utility companies or the city can initiate court proceedings. At the end of 2020, more than 151,000 residential PGW customers and nearly 140,000 residential PECO customers were behind on their bills and at risk of service termination. And more than 72,000 PWD customers could have had their water turned off if the city’s public health moratorium weren’t still in place.

As COVID-19’s health and economic effects continue to take a toll on the country, and as the existing moratoriums on evictions and utility shut-offs begin to expire, Philadelphians need to make plans for navigating their debt. And we need to be thinking collectively about policies that can help.

To initiate the conversation, CLS and Pew hosted a virtual event on March 2, moderated by Amadee Braxton of WURD-AM, for the community to learn more about each organizations’ research. Afterwards, Philadelphians in debt were invited to participate in smaller, private conversations about their experiences. Watch a video recording of the public presentation here.

Elinor Haider is the director of The Pew Charitable Trusts’ Philadelphia research and policy initiative. Deborah Freedman is the executive director of Community Legal Services of Philadelphia.

This op-ed was originally published by The Philadelphia Inquirer on February 26, 2021.

The front facade of the Supreme Court of the United States in Washington, DC.
ian-hutchinson-U8WfiRpsQ7Y-unsplash.jpg_master

Agenda for America

A collection of resources to help federal, state, and local decision-makers set an achievable agenda for all Americans

Quick View

Data-driven policymaking is not just a tool for finding new solutions for emerging challenges, it makes government more effective and better able to serve the public interest.

Lightbulbs
Lightbulbs

States of Innovation

Data-driven state policy innovations across America

Quick View

Data-driven policymaking is not just a tool for finding new solutions for difficult challenges. When states serve their traditional role as laboratories of innovation, they increase the American people’s confidence that the government they choose—no matter the size—can be effective, responsive, and in the public interest.

Philadelphia Municipal Court
Philadelphia Municipal Court
Report

How Philadelphia Municipal Court's Civil Division Works

Quick View
Report

In Philadelphia, the Municipal Court is the lowest rung of the judicial system, with a civil division that heard roughly 91,000 cases in 2018, the latest year for which full data is available.

Philadelphia
Philadelphia
Article

Where Philadelphia's Small Claims Court Defendants Live

Quick View
Article

Approximately 91,000 cases are filed annually in Philadelphia Municipal Court’s Civil Division, predominantly small claims cases seeking under $12,000 (often less than $5,000), landlord-tenant disputes, and code enforcement violations issued by the city.

South Philadelphia
South Philadelphia
Article

Who are Philadelphia's Landlords?

Quick View
Article

The COVID-19 pandemic has highlighted rental property owners’ role in determining whether Philadelphia residents have safe and affordable places to live. But incomplete and nonstandardized data make it hard to compile and analyze information about Philadelphia’s landlords.