As the Ocean Heats Up, Governments Should Prepare for Future Climate Changes

At U.N. meeting, it’s time for countries to agree to the adaptive management needed to keep fisheries sustainable

Navigate to:

As the Ocean Heats Up, Governments Should Prepare for Future Climate Changes
A group of fishing vessels on the water, docked at a jetty. Seabirds fly above the water extending to the shore in the horizon.
A group of fishing vessels moored at a dock in Morocco. Across the globe, the impacts of climate change present additional challenges for fishers and managers working to maintain the long-term health of valuable species.
Bim Getty Images

With ocean temperatures at their hottest ever, it’s hard to ignore the impact climate change has already had on marine biodiversity and fisheries. Fish populations are moving to cooler waters, coral bleaching has increased and algal blooms are larger and more frequent than ever. When coupled with overfishing, still the largest problem facing the ocean, the future for some of the world’s most valuable and ecologically important species is being threatened.

Although the regional fisheries management organizations (RFMOs) responsible for managing valuable international fisheries have started recognizing the effects of climate change on their fisheries and initiated actions that consider its impacts in their management plans, they need to do more to conserve wildlife and sustain the fisheries that create tens of thousands of jobs and feed millions of people each year.

The meeting at United Nations headquarters in New York this week is an opportunity to spur further action. Parties to the United Nations Fish Stocks Agreement, which governs the “conservation and sustainable use” of globally shared fish stocks, will meet from 15-17 May to specifically discuss how warming oceans are affecting international fisheries and how best to respond. Pew has three major recommendations for RFMOs: Adopt climate adaptive harvest strategies for fisheries, transition away from single-species management to ecosystem-based fisheries management (EBFM) and enact reforms that address how climate change could increase illegal, unreported and unregulated (IUU) fishing.

Harvest strategies prepare fisheries for future ocean changes

Harvest strategies, which are also known as management procedures, are adaptive tools that can be designed to address the projected impacts of climate change in fisheries management. Harvest strategies are pre-agreed frameworks that use computer models to test a range of future scenarios for fisheries, including potential ocean temperature increases and stock movement; they are used to set long-term objectives for fisheries. For example, they should automatically adjust fishing limits based on population status and environmental variability, which takes the guesswork out of annual management negotiations. In regions such as the Pacific, where species like tuna migrate through the waters managed by the Inter-American Tropical Tuna Commission and the Western and Central Pacific Fisheries Commission, collaborative management and regional coordination can make harvest strategies even more effective by ensuring that the same rules are in place. This will be particularly important in the face of climate change, which is expected to cause fish to move from west to east across the boundary separating these management groups.

Climate change affects not only tuna populations, but entire ecosystems

As more RFMO-managed stocks transition to harvest strategies, EBFM is the next frontier. This method recognizes that fisheries do not happen in isolation and considers the health of the full ecosystem, including how fishing for one species can affect predator-prey relationships, non-target species and important habitats such as breeding and feeding grounds. With climate change moving fish stocks and affecting food supply, it naturally changes where fisheries are located and how managers govern them effectively. RFMOs are already adopting and implementing harvest strategies for tuna fisheries, but these can be strengthened by including EBFM and ensuring that as fishing and the ocean change, the wider ecosystems remain as healthy as possible despite warming.

Warming seas could lead to more illegal activity, so new strategies are needed

As fish move farther out of their traditional ranges because of climate change, fishers may have a harder time finding them or profiting from their catch. Commercial fishers may resort to cutting corners on crew safety or turn to IUU fishing to replace lost revenue. They may also encroach on coastal areas, depleting fresh catch for local people. RFMOs need to not only prevent overfishing but work to ensure that the practices and rules they put in place to prevent IUU fishing incorporate knowledge about how climate change could make some vessel operators and owners embrace illegal fishing in an effort to maintain short-term profitability. Sharing vessel tracking information along with transparency of vessel ownership and access agreements to fishing grounds could help fisheries managers better prepare for and address such challenges.

The changes facing the ocean and fishing are coming quickly, and fisheries managers need to prepare for the reality of what warming waters mean for fish populations and the industries that rely on them. Although rapid, large-scale emissions reductions are needed to avoid crossing ecological thresholds beyond which adaptation measures will no longer be effective for fisheries, there are still many steps managers can take in the face of the shifts already happening. The upcoming U.N. meeting is a critical opportunity to face reality head-on and commit to protecting the health and resilience of fisheries and the wider ecosystem.

Andrew Clayton, Grantly Galland, and Peter Horn are project directors working on Pew’s international fisheries project.

National Homeownership Month

Elisabetta Zavoli/Getty Images
Elisabetta Zavoli/Getty Images
Issue Brief

Improve Fisheries Management with Better Questions

Quick View
Issue Brief

Good scientific advice is the fuel that drives the engine of fisheries management. When managers want to develop comprehensive, long-term policies for measures such as catch limits or gear restrictions, they pose questions related to their policy goals, which scientists then do their best to answer. And the more ambitious the question, the more far-reaching the advice.

rope pile
rope pile
Issue Brief

Governments Progress on UN Fish Stocks Agreement

Quick View
Issue Brief

The United Nations Fish Stocks Agreement (UNFSA) has governed worldwide “long-term conservation and sustainable use” of shared fish stocks—those that bridge the legal boundaries separating the waters of nations, mainly tunas and sharks—since 2001. Yet more than 20 years on, a new analysis from The Pew Charitable Trusts finds that, despite some notable progress, countries still are not meeting important legal obligations under the agreement, even as advances in scientific knowledge present critical opportunities to update UNFSA’s decades- old provisions.

Composite image of modern city network communication concept

Learn the Basics of Broadband from Our Limited Series

Sign up for our four-week email course on Broadband Basics

Quick View

How does broadband internet reach our homes, phones, and tablets? What kind of infrastructure connects us all together? What are the major barriers to broadband access for American communities?

What Is Antibiotic Resistance—and How Can We Fight It?

Sign up for our four-week email series The Race Against Resistance.

Quick View

Antibiotic-resistant bacteria, also known as “superbugs,” are a major threat to modern medicine. But how does resistance work, and what can we do to slow the spread? Read personal stories, expert accounts, and more for the answers to those questions in our four-week email series: Slowing Superbugs.