Oyster Restoration Offers New Market for Shellfish Farmers

Initiative could help growers, ecosystem, and coastal communities

Oyster Restoration Offers New Market for Shellfish Farmers
Brian Gennaco, owner of Virgin Oyster Co., pulls up a bag filled with large oysters from his farm on Little Bay in Durham, New Hampshire. Farmers in New Hampshire and six other states are selling overgrown oysters for use in reef restoration projects.
Jerry and Marcy Monkman/EcoPhotography
Tim Henry (right) and Ken Smaldone of Bay Point Oyster Co. haul an oyster cage onto their pontoon boat on Little Bay in Durham, New Hampshire. In addition to filtering water, oyster reefs help protect shorelines and provide shelter for wildlife.
Jerry and Marcy Monkman/EcoPhotography
These oysters from the Bay Point Oyster Co. farm on Little Bay in Durham, New Hampshire, will be transplanted onto a nearby reef that was created to help the bay’s native oyster population rebound.
Jerry and Marcy Monkman/EcoPhotography
Brian Gennaco, owner of Virgin Oyster Co., sorts oysters from his farm on Little Bay in Durham, New Hampshire. Reef restoration projects, such as those that are part of the Supporting Oyster Aquaculture and Restoration initiative, may become a new market for shellfish farmers.
Jerry and Marcy Monkman/EcoPhotography
Steve Weglarz of Cedar Point Oyster Farm separates oysters so they can be transplanted into a reef in Little Bay in Durham, New Hampshire. Healthy oyster reefs help coastal ecosystems thrive and can lessen the impact of storms on communities.
Jerry and Marcy Monkman/EcoPhotography
Alix Laferriere, left, and Brianna Group of The Nature Conservancy and Steve Weglarz of Cedar Point Oyster Company inspect oysters for the Supporting Oyster Aquaculture and Restoration (SOAR) initiative on Great Bay in Durham, New Hampshire. Native oysters—both reproducing and nonreproductive varieties—are being used in the restoration efforts.
Jerry and Marcy Monkman/EcoPhotography
Brian Gennaco of Virgin Oyster Co. readies oysters for transplanting to a restoration reef in Great Bay in Durham, New Hampshire. Supporting Oyster Aquaculture and Restoration officials hope to populate 27 acres of reefs across 20 restoration sites along the East Coast and the Pacific Northwest.
Jerry and Marcy Monkman/EcoPhotography
Brianna Group of The Nature Conservancy and Steve Weglarz of Cedar Point Oyster Company add oysters to a restoration reef near Nanny Island on Great Bay in Durham, New Hampshire.
Jerry and Marcy Monkman/EcoPhotography

This year has been hard on shellfish farmers, with sales to restaurants way down because of the COVID-19 pandemic. That has left many farmers holding oysters even as they grew beyond the ideal size for the half-shell market, and has created a major dilemma over what to do with those oversized bivalves.

Now, there’s a new option on the table. Under a partnership called Supporting Oyster Aquaculture and Restoration (SOAR), eligible growers in seven states—Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New York, and Washington—can sell their overgrown oysters for use in reef restoration projects.

How oyster reefs help coastal ecosystems

Oyster reefs help protect shorelines, filter water, and provide habitat for wildlife. Sadly, U.S. native oyster populations have declined to a fraction of their historic levels because of over harvesting, pollution, and habitat destruction. But rebuilding shellfish habitats is one of the most promising opportunities for reviving coastal ecosystems, and states’ investments in oyster reef restoration have yielded results in recent years. 

Still, one challenge for restoration practitioners has been the time, money, and effort needed to raise baby oysters to a size that increases their chance of survival once transplanted to a reef. Adding large, healthy, adult oysters through the SOAR initiative could rapidly accelerate progress on the restoration projects.

SOAR was developed by Pew and The Nature Conservancy, with guidance and support from state and federal agencies. It is the largest partnership between growers and restoration experts to date, with $2 million in funding, and expects to buy at least 5 million oysters to populate 27 acres of reefs across 20 restoration sites. SOAR program leads anticipate that more than 100 shellfish companies will sell to the program, and that revenue from those sales will help support 200 jobs in New England, the Mid-Atlantic, and Washington state.

The program will purchase only native oysters—specifically, the Eastern (or American) oyster on the U.S. East Coast and the Olympia oyster in the Pacific Northwest—because non-native species can disrupt ecosystems, in part by outcompeting native species. SOAR will also accept both naturally reproducing oysters, which help reefs grow, and nonreproductive varieties, which contribute other benefits to the ecosystem. Growers can learn more at nature.org/SOAR.

The initiative builds upon similar, smaller-scale efforts in New Hampshire, Rhode Island, Washington, and other states over the past several years. Pew hopes SOAR can catalyze greater collaboration between oyster growers and states, conservationists, and other stakeholders, and that reef restoration projects can become a new market for shellfish farmers. Accomplishing these goals would benefit growers, shellfish populations, and coastal ecosystems and communities.

Joseph Gordon is a director and Aaron Kornbluth and Zack Greenberg are officers with The Pew Charitable Trusts’ campaign to protect marine life on the U.S. East Coast.